Sometimes truth is stranger than fiction...
Despite Mel Gibson's antisemitic remarks in the past, he has announced that he is creating a film about the story of Judah the Maccabee. Although Jews view this as a uniquely Jewish story - after all, we have a whole holiday called Hanukkah to celebrate it - some Christians consider the Book of Maccabees to be part of the biblical canon. Jews do not; for us it is part of the apocrypha - books to be studied but not revered.
An article about Mel Gibson and the Maccabees appearing on Jewish Ideas Daily maintains that contrary to expectations, Gibson might be the right person to make this movie. The premise of the article appears to be that as long as we are not seeking theology or historical accuracy in the film, it will probably be quite enjoyable. Gibson is know for his epic films, with complex heroes and big bloody battles (Braveheart, anyone?). If all you're looking for in a movie is entertainment, this one promises to live up to expectations.
In contrast to this article, the ADL is protesting the making of this movie. The president of the organization complained that a person with no respect for the Jewish heritage and the Jewish people should not be making a film which portrays them. However, it is unlikely that movie-goers will think they are getting a real history lesson, so the ADL and other Jewish organizations should probably focus their efforts on issues that matter more.
No comments:
Post a Comment